Monte Ammons 0:00 I get all the time. There's nothing like this in the market. And my first question to them is, you better find out why. Because if there's nothing in the market and you've got all these multinationals who have millions of dollars for R and D and brilliant minds working on it, they don't have something in a white space, you probably better step back and ask why.
Keren Novack 0:18 Products don't fail in the boardroom, they fail on the shelf. Every day, brand leaders face the same questions. Why do some products win while others don't? What do consumers actually want? Vers. What are we just assuming? And how do you build products that succeed in the real world? Well, that's exactly why we made this podcast. I'm Karin Novak. This is behind the Shelf and it's brought to you by Kurion. In each episode, I sit down with founders, product leaders, and industry experts to unpack what really drives product success. From innovation and testing to consumer behavior and market trends. No guesswork, no buzzwords, just real insights backed by real consumer. If you're building, refining, or scaling products, you're in the right place. Welcome to behind the Shelf. Today's guest is Monte Ammons, founder of Liquid Sherpas and a veteran of the beverage industry. Over Monte's career, he's worked with restaurant trains, major brands like Coca Cola, other ingredient suppliers, and startups. This has given him a front row seat to what it actually takes to turn a consumer need into a product that can scale, scale, and succeed in the marketplace. But what was especially interesting to me about his perspective is he's not just speaking as a founder of single successful brand like I'm usually talking to on this show. But he's helped hundreds of brands navigate the journey from idea to shelf. And he's seen firsthand why so many products fail before consumers even have a chance to buy them. So in this episode, we're talking about my favorite horrifying fact. Why do more than 90% of new product launches fail? And how consumer insights, my favorite topic, gets lost on the journey from idea to shelf. And what is it that's separating products that scale from products that become really expensive? Shelf clutter. Monte, welcome to behind the Shelf.
Monte Ammons 2:16 Thank you. Thank you for having me. Looking forward to our conversation.
Keren Novack 2:20 I am as well. But before we get into all of that, before we go behind the shelf, let's go behind you. Because you've spent your career watching products succeed and fail from nearly every angle imaginable. And. But was there a moment in your career that changed how you think about what makes a product successful? vack: I am as well. But before we get into all of that, before we go behind the shelf, let's go behind you. Because you've spent your career watching products succeed and fail from nearly every angle imaginable. And. But was there a moment in your career that changed how you think about what makes a product successful?
Monte Ammons 2:39 Yeah, actually very early on, and I started my career in marketing, heavy in food service, and found my way into a little bit of product development. I'm not a food scientist, nor do I claim to be one, but have spent a lot of time navigating and building the process and guiding people through the process. And when I was early in my career starting out in food service and doing some development work there as a marketer, you come to the table and say, I've got an idea. Here's a white spot in the marketplace, here's something the consumer is looking for and then you get it into restaurants. And the restaurant world is quite challenging because especially qsr quick service restaurants because you've generally got a kid from high school, right, who's disengaged and not really wanting to be there, and you're asking him to execute this brilliant idea that tastes wonderful, that the consumer will love. And so many times it gets lost in translation. And one of the things that I learned early on was really that execution and the ability to replicate that over and over and over again in a cost effective manner was really the difference between success and failure. You can have the greatest idea on the planet, but if you can't replicate it and get that done over and over again, it's going to fail. It doesn't matter how great, it takes one time. But really great ideas fail if they can't scale. And that just kind of became a mantra of mine and it started in my experience in the food service world.
Keren Novack 4:12 That's really fascinating. I think it goes back to a lot of the trust that consumers have to build within a brand. You buy it once, you love it, you go back again, and if it's not the same, that trust is broken. And that trust is, it's very fragile with consumers, right?
Monte Ammons 4:29 Absolutely. And you don't get any do overs. There's so many choices in the market, you get one crack at it.
Keren Novack 4:36 I mean, it's my favorite and also most horrifying thing is to walk down the aisle of a grocery store. It is so crowded. And yeah, if I've had a bad experience once, if it didn't live up to the hype that either was planned or I had had that first time, it's gone. So yeah, being able to scale and replicate that is really important. Beyond that, when you look at the products that ultimately win, okay, they're scalable and they're replicable, what do they all have in common?
Monte Ammons 5:02 I would say that you've really hit the nail on the head, it's the ability to scale and to be produced uniformly, reliably, consistently and cost effectively at a mass scale. And if you can't do that, you might have a nice little cottage business, but you're never going to be able to make that product break out. And it's so critical. Great ideas die if they can't be replicated. 's the ability to scale and to be produced uniformly, reliably, consistently and cost effectively at a mass scale. And if you can't do that, you might have a nice little cottage business, but you're never going to be able to make that product break out. And it's so critical. Great ideas die if they can't be replicated.
Keren Novack 5:29 Yeah. So no matter how much a consumer need exists, if we can't scale beyond that, it is going to just live in that moment there.
Monte Ammons 5:39 Exactly. And if it can't scale, it's ultimately going to die. Unfortunately, you've got to have scale to grow and survive and thrive. And if you can't replicate, it's a nice little one off, but it just can't survive. And I think that's a big part of why you have 80 to 90% failure rate of new products is the inability to scale.
Keren Novack 6:00 Yeah, I think, I suspect a lot of founders don't actually understand the cost that is involved in scaling a product and the hard work that goes on behind the scenes.
Monte Ammons 6:11 Yeah, really the complexity is. I see time and time again with founders, it's underappreciated is where founders, what I see, founders and even multinationals fall into this trap of they go to what's sexy first? Branding in the formulation. That's the sexy part. That's what you want to dive right into. But it's almost like building a house. If I just start building a house by grabbing a hammer and some nails and some two by fours, I can build something, but it's probably not going to be something anybody wants to live in. And so even multinationals get away from the habit of doing the upfront due diligence. And we're kind of building that blueprint.
Keren Novack 6:54 Right.
Monte Ammons 6:54 You got to have that architectural rendering with everything thought through before you start grabbing the first hammer or nail or the whole thing's going to fall apart. And that's a discipline that I think is largely lost and kind of unappreciated. Particularly when founders, if they're coming into product development with one line of sight and one unique part of their background, be it marketing, be it operations, be it sales, be it formulation, they don't look holistically at everything that's interrelated. So they don't do that blueprint up front. And it's almost like building a. If I'm going to build a house, I've got to think through number one, is my land even zone for me to put a house on it? Right. What are the Regulatory considerations, who's going to live into in it? What do they need? What materials am I going to need? So all of that goes so frequently overlooked. And that's why there's this failure rate, because you get into it and you go, oh my gosh, I can't even get to the house. I haven't built a driveway or it's not handicap compatible, I can't get up the stairs or I can't buy the materials that I have to buy. So that's what I see time and time and time again that really derails so many products. this failure rate, because you get into it and you go, oh my gosh, I can't even get to the house. I haven't built a driveway or it's not handicap compatible, I can't get up the stairs or I can't buy the materials that I have to buy. So that's what I see time and time and time again that really derails so many products.
Keren Novack 8:10 Let's talk about the consumer at the end of this because I've did some homework here. Listen to a few podcasts that you were on and one of the things I heard you say a few times is that founders often fall in love with products, ideas and trends before they fully understand the consumer need that they're trying to solve. Why do you think that's such a common trap for founders?
Monte Ammons 8:30 I think it's because the development piece and the branding piece are fun. Thinking through all of the interrelated things around, can I get the ingredients for this? Can I make this profitable? Can I put it in a package that maybe isn't beautiful, but I have to have the processing that's hard to think through to make those connection points between what the consumer needs and wants and what can I realistically do within kind of the laws of physics and nature? And it's hard for people to get their heads wrapped around in to. If I've got one singular background, you know, that kind of lens that I look through, if it's a marketing researcher or if I'm a design person, it's really hard for me to step outside of that and have the experience to go, oh, I can't do that because I don't have the shelf life for it, or I can't put that in a convenience retail environment or it won't go D to C. So all of those things that are interrelated, it's really hard to do that work and it's heavy lifting to tie that back to the consumer and go, what's a non negotiable for the consumer, but at the same time a non negotiable in terms of what can actually be produced in scale. And that's really heavy lifted.
Keren Novack 9:55 Yeah, absolutely. It sounds to me like what you're saying is that founders and consumers are actually very similar in some sense. They want it fast, they want it cheap, they want it sustainable, and they want it to taste great. And at some point you can't have all three of those. You have to prioritize and getting that prioritization right has to align with what's feasible to scale the product and what the consumer wants and what the brand wants to stay for. I often talk to people and say, what's your non negotiable as you scale this brand, what is the one thing you're not going to give up?
Monte Ammons 10:27 Absolutely, that's a great point. It's really a negotiation of the non negotiables, right?
Keren Novack 10:34 Absolutely. When we talked a couple of weeks ago, you said that consumer data often gets handed off and interpreted differently, one group to the next group. Where do you think some of those non negotiables or the voice of consumer most commonly get lost between the initial insight and the product that actually ultimately ends up on shelf? alked a couple of weeks ago, you said that consumer data often gets handed off and interpreted differently, one group to the next group. Where do you think some of those non negotiables or the voice of consumer most commonly get lost between the initial insight and the product that actually ultimately ends up on shelf?
Monte Ammons 10:56 I think what tends to happen is there's a lack of communication across different functional areas. So you may have one person that's driving that consumer insight and then that is the voice of what the consumer ultimately wants. But you don't have inputs along the way of how do you get there. So I can have a great consumer insight that says the consumer wants a beverage that has these attributes at this price point and the convenience, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. But I don't necessarily have someone or a host of people that are helping me guide that process. And what ultimately happens is you've got somebody that's kind of the North Star for the consumer, but loses, doesn't have the ability to say, okay, it's got to go through this step, it's got to have this non negotiable for the consumer to actually get it and use it and be 70% of what the consumer wants. And instead you get close to the finish line and you've neglected something that the whole proposition falls apart because you just don't have that line of sight into it. So what I see over and over again is you almost have to have whoever owns the consumer proposition has to be very inquisitive about not just what does the consumer want, but what does it take to get that proposition across the finish line. So you've got to become multidisciplinary and seek out the other stakeholders and make sure that what you're putting together can live within the brand. You talked about that. Does it align with the brand and can you actually get it to the consumer? And that means you gotta have some knowledge of the channel you're going into.
Keren Novack 12:47 Right.
Monte Ammons 12:48 Will the retailer does it work for them? So you gotta think about all those stakeholders along the way. So it's very challenging for anybody who's kind of the voice of the consumer and getting it from just the rough idea, that white space all the way to the product on the shelf.
Novack Right.
Monte Ammons 12:48 Will the retailer does it work for them? So you gotta think about all those stakeholders along the way. So it's very challenging for anybody who's kind of the voice of the consumer and getting it from just the rough idea, that white space all the way to the product on the shelf.
Keren Novack 13:05 Fascinating. Yeah, that reminds me of a project I worked on years ago. It's a breakfast product and the consumer told us loud and clear it has to have a fresh egg. We don't want egg syrup or whatever else it might have been or any sort of fake egg in any way. We want a fresh egg. And so you've got team members going, well, we need to deliver the fresh egg. And it's like, well hang on, time out a second. How are we going to deliver a fresh egg in each individual one of these? What if the egg breaks? You've now not just lost an egg, you've lost an entire package of what it is. And so ultimately we got to a great place with it and how to deliver this fre. But I saw there people just tripping over themselves thinking, well that's what the consumer wants, so that's what it needs to be. Where someone else is going, well, that can't be, you know, so the bridge isn't the connections, they can get tripped over pretty easily there when it comes to that.
Monte Ammons 14:00 That's a great insight. And if you think about it, that discipline and that rigor really forces some what can be game changing innovation. Because you have to step back from it and go, okay, maybe I can't take the path I was thinking about, but if this is a non negotiable for the consumer, how do we solve that need in maybe a non traditional way? And you've got to have those cross functional teams to be able to help you get out of that box and think about it differently. So it's really where a lot of people think of it as rigor and kind of discipline. To me it drives so much kind of groundbreaking innovation. If you really bring these teams together and do it.
Keren Novack 14:43 Absolutely. I mean I can generally tell if a product is going to be successful with these big multinational brands because if I'm sitting in the back room working on a call talking about a product coming and I've got someone there from finance, I've got someone there from nutrition, consumer insights, marketing, regulation, that product I know is going to succeed because you have everybody thinking and working together on it. It's when you're just talking to one of those team members that it can be isolating and things go into a silo and then they get lost. So you've worked with a lot of founders over the years. I think I understand what you're going to say here, but I'm going to ask it. But I'm asking it from the lens of what's the homework that founders should do before they're truly ready to build a product or I know incoming work to work for you. I've heard you say you. I don't work with just anybody. What's that kind of preventable mistake that you see over and over again that needs to be sort of worked out until they're ready to scale? s the homework that founders should do before they're truly ready to build a product or I know incoming work to work for you. I've heard you say you. I don't work with just anybody. What's that kind of preventable mistake that you see over and over again that needs to be sort of worked out until they're ready to scale?
Monte Ammons 15:43 Yeah, I sound like a broken record on this. And the clients I work with, they're like, can you talk about something different? But really on the front end, whether you call it a development brief, a project brief, a product brief, whatever you call it, there needs to be some discipline on the front end. It's that blueprint I was talking about. And so few people go through that discipline. And it's really stepping back from the product that people fall in love with. I get all the time there's nothing like this in the market. And my first question to them is, you better find out why. Because if there's nothing in the market and you've got all these multinationals who have millions of dollars for R and D and brilliant minds working on it, they don't have something in a white space, you probably better step back and ask why. So start there. If it's completely different, how does it succeed? And you better understand what is different about it, right? And really spend some time understanding the consumer need. What is the consumer telling you? And you got to do a lot of that, right? Especially if you're doing something new and innovative, the consumer can't tell you because they haven't seen it yet, they haven't touched it, they haven't felt it. But you have to do as much due diligence as you can to say, back to your example of breakfast, can we do that? Can I make that happen? Can I do it cost effectively? How would I put that together?
Keren Novack 17:03 Right?
Monte Ammons 17:03 The how is even more important than the what at that stage. And I see so many founders that they bristle at that, right? Because I'll send them back time and time again, well, have you thought about this? What about this? What about this? What about this? And they go, well, I just need to get the product done. Like, well, you're probably going to get halfway through and find out that you should have asked that question. And it's going to cost you six months and a lot of money to go back and do over. So I see that time and time again. That's the advice I always have. Again, I'm a broken record. t need to get the product done. Like, well, you're probably going to get halfway through and find out that you should have asked that question. And it's going to cost you six months and a lot of money to go back and do over. So I see that time and time again. That's the advice I always have. Again, I'm a broken record.
Keren Novack 17:35 No, it is really, truly such a good lesson. I think there's a couple of things I've taken away from all of these conversations I've been having that is asking those questions, like how am I going to source that really rare ingredient from that one country that only is grown in one field enough to get into all of these stores and to keep the product there and do it in a way that is going to have the shelf life that's required. There's so many questions, but unless you've experienced that over and over and over again, like yourself, how would you know that? If you read about all of these founders just whipping up a batch of product in their kitchen and then suddenly they're selling it to PepsiCo or whoever else. But for every one of those stories,
Monte Ammons 18:18 there's 90 and every one of those is it's a 10 to 15 year ride. And it was a lot of iterations of that. A lot of what I see from a founder that succeeds. When you look for what makes a great founder, a founder, especially early on, has to be flexible and be able to call their own baby ugly. Because it's so rare that you come out of the gate and you hit a home run. I mean, look at Poppy. That was reinvented three times before it finally caught fire. And not just minor do overs, right? It was major reworks and a founder has to be able to step back and go, this isn't working. Why isn't it working? What was flawed about my idea? And that's really hard, right? That's really hard because as a founder, you've got to believe what nobody else believes. You've got a vision and it's hard to go. My vision might be 15 degrees off.
Keren Novack 19:16 I think that might be my line from this episode is, you've got to be willing to call your baby ugly. You know, it's interesting as I was talking to someone not too long ago and they said, yeah, I've received some really bad feedback on this product, but it's okay because some people love it. And it's like, ooh, let's rewind there a little bit and really, let's listen to those people because we might learn more from that series of negative feedback or constructive feedback, I like to say, than you would from somebody who's going to follow over it. There'll always be someone that'll fall all over a product. But what can you learn from those that. Not a huge fan of your products?
Monte Ammons 19:52 Yeah. And it's usually one of the traps people fall into is it's usually their friends and family that are saying, this is great. This is great. What are they going to tell you? Your baby's hideous. I'm sorry. r a product. But what can you learn from those that. Not a huge fan of your products? Yeah. And it's usually one of the traps people fall into is it's usually their friends and family that are saying, this is great. This is great. What are they going to tell you? Your baby's hideous. I'm sorry.
Keren Novack 20:03 That is gold. I'm going to use that one. So let's fast forward a little bit here. We have a product. We've scaled it. It is repeatable, and it's on the shelf. A lot of times on this podcast we talk about getting on the shelf is really tough. We get that. But what we always say is staying on the shelf is sometimes even harder, especially in these crowded places. So what do you think separates products that get on the shelf and they do it well, but then end up disappearing versus those that become repeat purchases time and time again?
Monte Ammons 20:39 I think it really goes back to how you design the product and how mindful you are about the product and how well designed it is. Because a poorly designed product, even if it tastes great or looks great or has great branding, if it's very difficult to execute, it's eventually going to die under its own way. So if it's the planning that you put into it is almost a predictor of how well you can execute it. And that's where I think a lot of products kind of fall by the wayside. They can start hot. But the difficulty of keeping that flywheel turning because of something inherent in the product is what kills so many of these brands just as they're kind of starting to take off. And part of the discipline of staying on the shelf is being able to go back and look at the product and go, okay, we're having an issue operationally, what's driving that? What's the reason for that? And probably 70% of the time, it's something inherent in the product. And that's where your innovation has to look inward and go to optimization. And so many people, I think, forget that, that once the product's on the shelf, that's to your point. That's just the starting point. Now you got to keep it there. And sometimes that means reinventing that product because something you didn't think about early on, and people are like, well, it just died because consumers didn't accept it. No, there was probably something really good there, but it died because you didn't nurture it. You didn't help it take its next evolutionary step. sometimes that means reinventing that product because something you didn't think about early on, and people are like, well, it just died because consumers didn't accept it. No, there was probably something really good there, but it died because you didn't nurture it. You didn't help it take its next evolutionary step.
Keren Novack 22:17 I always say good research Never dies. There's always going to be another question. There's always going to be another optimization. To think that your first formula on the shelf is going to be your last formula on the shelf. Unless you're exiting the shelf. That's not the case. You need, because you're going to have to change an ingredient at some point. You're going to have to adapt to the next consumer movement in the food and Bev space. You're going to have to adapt to the age of your consumers, whatever it might be. There is going to be little tweaks that happen along the way and you have to keep touch with that. This has been a very interesting perspective of what it takes to build the product and really make sure that it is something that can be reproduced over and over again at a way that is scalable for both the business and the consumer. So, Monte, at the end of every episode, I do a shelf check. This is racket fire answers only. Although I've yet to have a question that is truly rapid fire. But we'll see. Let's go here. So I've got a couple questions here for you. What is the better predictor of long term success? The product experience or the branding?
Monte Ammons 23:32 I would say the product experience. It has to live up to the branding, otherwise it's going to eventually fail.
Keren Novack 23:39 All right. Yeah. Well, if it's living up to the branding, that's a good product experience, I suppose I would argue so, yes, I completely agree with you there. What's more dangerous? Having a great product nobody can find or great distribution for a product consumers won't buy twice, or in your case,
Monte Ammons 23:57 can't scale great distribution with no repeat? That's a recipe for disaster every time. That's what we talked about. If you got great distribution and no repeat, you better go back to the drawing board and figure out why, Right?
Keren Novack 24:11 Absolutely. What is one thing behind the shelf that consumers never see but should appreciate more?
Monte Ammons 24:18 I think what we've been talking about, just the complexity of what goes into bringing a product to market, the strategic thought that should go into it and how everything is interrelated. Whenever you put a product together, it's not just the great brand or the great formulas or a great price. Everything kind of interweaves and I don't think the consumer sees or appreciates all the complexity that goes into building a winning product.
Keren Novack 24:47 Just stuck some liquid in a can and we're shipping it out the door. Right. All right, let's see if you can answer this one because I know you do work With a lot of founders. What's a beverage trend that founders are chasing that you're a little bit cautious of right now? ding a winning product. Just stuck some liquid in a can and we're shipping it out the door. Right. All right, let's see if you can answer this one because I know you do work With a lot of founders. What's a beverage trend that founders are chasing that you're a little bit cautious of right now?
Monte Ammons 25:01 So I'm a little bit cautious of trend chasing in general. I believe trends are inherently kind of faddish and a fad is not something I want to by nature kind of short lived. I always encourage my clients to go to the consumer need because the trend is a manifestation of the consumer need. Right. It's a short term solution for the consumer need. And if you get to the consumer need rather than the trend, that's got legs, that's got longevity. So when people say, I'm building a protein beverage, like, okay, what need is that, sir? And why is it different and where you going to source your volume from if everybody else is playing in the same space? So I like to go back to the consumer need, what's the consumer really asking for? And figure out a different way to deliver it.
Keren Novack 25:56 Bingo. You're speaking my language. I just read an article about trends versus movements. And a movement is the consumer need. You can have a trend within a movement. Protein, coffee, anybody. But the movement there is. We need more protein in our diets and we're going to get that from a number of different ways. But you've got to solve the need for it first. All right, last one is, you've worked with a lot of founders, said that over and over again here. But what's one piece of advice that you find yourself repeating over and over again? For those in the back that haven't
Monte Ammons 26:26 been listening, here we go again. Right? It's really when you're doing a product, when you're developing a new product, don't start with the sexy stuff. Go into the weeds. Go and do a product brief, or development brief, whatever you want to call it. And don't do it in a silo, don't do it in a vacuum. Because you're going to have a limited line of sight and limited expertise. Get some fellow Sherpas, right? Some people who have climbed that mountain before and looked at it from different lenses and have different areas of expertise, bring them in and have them encourage them to pick holes in it. Ask them to call your baby ugly so you can see how to improve it. Because the best place to build a beautiful baby at the beginning, right? Start with good genes.
Keren Novack 27:14 I love that. Well, you guys, you heard it all here first. Don't start with the sexy stuff. Call your baby ugly and get some help. Because there's a lot of questions you don't even know to ask when you first begin. Monty, this was such a great conversation. Thanks for joining me on behind the Shelf and sharing your perspective. I really, really appreciate it.
Monte Ammons 27:36 Thanks so much for having me. This was fun. Thank you. ome help. Because there's a lot of questions you don't even know to ask when you first begin. Monty, this was such a great conversation. Thanks for joining me on behind the Shelf and sharing your perspective. I really, really appreciate it. Thanks so much for having me. This was fun. Thank you.
Keren Novack 27:39 That's it for this episode of behind the Shelf. If you found this conversation useful, don't keep it to yourself. Share it with colleagues, friends, people who are building a business too. Make sure to like, follow, subscribe so you never miss an episode. And if you want more real world consumer insights, stay connected with us at Curion. Until next time. Keep testing, keep learning and keep building products. People choose.