Keren Novack 0:02 Welcome to behind the Shelf. Today we're joined by Simon Solis Cohen, founder of Huxley. Simon's perspective on what makes a good flavor started in his grandmother's garden, and it continued through the Culinary Institute of America, Michelin starred kitchens and Napa Valley wineries. And across his experience, he developed a pretty simple concept. When you begin with excellent ingredients, you don't need to overcomplicate the product. Well, that led him into the energy drink aisle, a category that has very traditionally been competing on caffeine and intensity and super extreme flavors. But Huxley takes a different approach. It was built around real fruit juice, moderate caffeine, and a product experience that was designed to be as enjoyable as it was functional. The brand has moved away from the traditional energy drink label and is positioned as an energy refresher. And today we're going to talk about the trade offs consumers have come to accept from energy drinks. What Simon learned once Huxley reached real consumers, and what it takes to turn trial into repeat purchase. Simon, welcome to behind the Shelf.
Simon Solis-Cohen 1:06 Thank you so much for having me.
Keren Novack 1:09 I'm very much enjoying my Huxley beverage right now. It is fantastic. We were able to get a case. I'm really excited to have you on the show today. Before I go behind the shelf, though, I really like to dive a little bit behind you. Before we start, what did all those experiences, from your grandmother's garden to the kitchens, to the wineries, teach you about product experience that became an absolute non negotiable when you entered the energy category? ow today. Before I go behind the shelf, though, I really like to dive a little bit behind you. Before we start, what did all those experiences, from your grandmother's garden to the kitchens, to the wineries, teach you about product experience that became an absolute non negotiable when you entered the energy category?
Simon Solis-Cohen 1:39 Yeah, no, I mean, it's a really great question because I really think it shows that differentiated view that I have on this category where in my opinion, I think that so many people think of this category as a function only category. And let's be honest, there's hundreds of energy brands out there and these days, thousands of functional beverages. Whether it's a protein or an energy source or any type of hydration product, there's a plethora of these things. And I feel like so many brands are so focused on function, they almost forget about the taste. Right. And let's be honest, a lot of it is just a bunch of, you know, lab made flavors that are thrown in and they call it a day, you know, and a lot of times that people are working with the flavor houses themselves to develop these flavors. And that seemed like a really backward process for me. And when I was thinking about how do we actually focus on consumer experience and make this good, it's all about taste. And that goes back to, you Know, my time working in, you know, restaurants and going to culinary school and working in the wine industry that, you know, at the end of the day, if it doesn't taste good, people don't come back. They don't buy it again. You don't get that repeat. And it's very expensive to keep trying to go find new customers. It's a lot cheaper and easier to keep the customers that have already found your product. Right. And there's not a shortage of people who can offer caffeine in a can. I'm not unique in that sense by any means, but what we can do is create a unique moment, which is actually actual enjoyment of taste. And the way I think about that, and I think, you know, one of the greatest, you know, kind of sayings out there that I picked up working in the wine industry specifically is that, you know, when we're talking about, you know, the best of the best Napa Valley wines, great wines are grown, they're not made. And a lot of wine Napa say that. And it's this idea that if you're doing your job right, you're growing a great wine. Because wine is all about the grape. It's not about how fancy the winemaker is. Once they pick it and press it and then go age it or do anything or blend it right, that's sort of the finishing of the product. But if you start with really, really poor quality grapes, you could use the finest French oak barrels. You can do all this blending and all this pizazz, it's going to be a bad wine because you started with a bad grape. And so for me, when I set out to create Huxleytz, we have to start from the highest quality ingredients and build up from there. And when we thought about what that highest quality ingredient was, it was really simple. It's real fruit juice. And for me, when I see different drinks out there that say, for instance, mango, and it says mango on the front of the can, and you turn it around and you read the ingredient list, and there's no mango in the ingredient list. That's where I was like, there's something wrong with that. And we need to approach this in a totally different way. different drinks out there that say, for instance, mango, and it says mango on the front of the can, and you turn it around and you read the ingredient list, and there's no mango in the ingredient list. That's where I was like, there's something wrong with that. And we need to approach this in a totally different way.
Keren Novack 4:32 Absolutely. But you could have taken this philosophy anywhere. Real ingredients, flavor. I mean, that fits anywhere in the grocery store, in the aisles. Why energy drinks?
Simon Solis-Cohen 4:43 Because I thought no one was doing it in energy drinks, you know, and for me, it was a fantastic white space. And, you know, I think that, let's be honest, the tam on the energy drink market is incredible. Right. I think we're about to be 24 billion dollar category here. And so that's exciting, right? To take on a really big tam and opportunity and to take on a category that is just seeing incredible, incredible growth. Like energy drinks have never slowed down. Right. You go map year after year after year. And so I thought if we can find an incredible category that's just growing like rapid fire, which energy seems to always be every year, but we can bring a true white space differentiated view to the category. And if you can actually pull that off, that's pretty frickin interesting if you ask me.
Keren Novack 5:31 Absolutely. I mean we as humans continue to be tired and need solutions for this. And as we've all matured in our human states, we have started to become a lot more conscious about what is in our products and a lot more discerning when we're choosing, choosing these items from grocery store shelves. So it's very refreshing. Sorry, that was a really bad pun. To see, to see drinks like this on the shelf that really are full of real ingredients. How did you arrive at 90 milligrams of caffeine and real fruit juice and cane sugar? Why those specific ingredients? What kind of resonated with you or with the consumers in those choices? efreshing. Sorry, that was a really bad pun. To see, to see drinks like this on the shelf that really are full of real ingredients. How did you arrive at 90 milligrams of caffeine and real fruit juice and cane sugar? Why those specific ingredients? What kind of resonated with you or with the consumers in those choices?
Simon Solis-Cohen 6:23 Yeah, I mean for me there's sort of two pieces to that. So the overarching thesis is everything in the can has to have service of flavor. And that was the number one guiding principle. Every ingredient in there and if it didn't taste good or was going to contribute negatively to the final flavor, we didn't want to use it. And then the other thing too is that when you go look at so many of these drinks these days, go like the ingredient list is a paragraph long. I mean, there is so much stuff that is unpronounceable there, you know, and exactly, it's unpronounceable. You don't know what it is. Five different sweeteners. Just because you're trying to game the system maybe on, you know, call outs and, and sugar content and things like this. And it's just like, it's just overly complicated, you know. And so when we were coming up with this, you know, I started with just a blank piece of paper and wanted to just write a brief of like, what do I want this to taste like, what I want this to feel like. And so the original kernel, though just like sentence that kicked this off was healthy energy drink with electrolytes. That was this original concept I had. And honestly I just pulled that out of thin air right I just kind of just thought about, like, this is kind of an interesting concept to play with as I was brainstorming what do I want to create. And when we started digging into that, I thought so much about that consumer experience. And the best analogy I had just coming from the alcohol world was I want Huxley to feel and taste like a champagne cocktail. And so when I think of that, I mean, I love a great champagne cocktail, right? And so I think about something like a blini, a mimosa, a Kira Royale, where you're taking, you know, a champagne or sparkling wine, you're adding some fruit juice or fruit liqueur to it. And what I think is so fun about those drinks, they're incredibly dangerous for me because they're so refreshing and easy to sip on. And that term sessionable is, I think, a really important term, right? People think about the word like session IPAs these days or session beers, right? Those are lower alcohol versions. So you can kind of, you know, have. Have a couple of them if you really wanted to, and enjoy them during the middle of the day, if that's your party style. But what's kind of interesting about it when you think of, like, this final product we've created, is that so many of the energy drink flavors out there today are indulgences. And that's very different than how we're thinking about it. And it's not to throw shade or criticize them. Those tons of companies out there selling billions of dollars of this stuff to please a lot of people, that's awesome. My point is that we didn't need to just offer more of the same, right? You have literally, candy collaboration flavors out there. You have these creamy, thick, you know, dessert like flavors. Awesome. There's a massive market for that, and those companies are doing a fantastic job delivering on that. So no one needed my point of view in that perspective. And so we said, well, let's look at the other side. Instead of these drinks tasting like indulgence and feeling like overstimulation, which, let's be honest, is what the majority of this category is, right? It's just more is more in a can with lots of caffeine, lots of this big artificial flavor, let's look at the opposite. Let's go where no one else is going. Let's zag when everyone's zigging here, right? And so basically what we're looking at is how do we make this light and fruity and refreshing, like that champagne cocktail? How do we make this not overstimulating and feel refreshing. So there's like, the physical feeling, and then, of course, there's the body feeling of how you feel after you drink it. And so we think about that from the taste perspective of real fruit juice is the only way to do that. Right. In my opinion, no amount of artificial flavor can really do that justice. And then things like 90 milligrams of caffeine, which is what the USDA states is one cup of, you know, coffee worth of caffeine. And that's how we arrived at that number. And so it's this idea, not feeling overstimulated, but actually feeling refreshed after you. amount of artificial flavor can really do that justice. And then things like 90 milligrams of caffeine, which is what the USDA states is one cup of, you know, coffee worth of caffeine. And that's how we arrived at that number. And so it's this idea, not feeling overstimulated, but actually feeling refreshed after you.
Keren Novack 10:19 There's no. And I'm susceptible to the caffeine jitters that I get. And it's actually part of the reason I've been taking the L Theanine in the mornings with the coffee is to help cool that. Which. This actually has 50 milligrams of that in here. There's no jitters that come with this. It's just a. I got this. I got my afternoon back.
Simon Solis-Cohen 10:38 Yeah. And I think, to me, like, I think this is a perfect lunchtime afternoon beverage. I mean, people do drink in the morning, don't get me wrong. But, like, I love coffee. I still want my coffee every morning. Don't get me wrong, I love the taste of coffee. So for me, this is that afternoon. Like, it's that pause. Like, if there's anything we can deliver to people, it's just that one moment where you can just pause in the middle of the day. There's a thousand notifications going off on your email or your phone. There's all that overwhelm you're feeling throughout the day. And you just get a moment to crack that can. You get this delicious, cold, lightly fizzy taste of real fruit. And it's just like. And you can exhale. And I just don't think many energy brands are selling the exhale. Right. They're selling this intensity. They're literally selling adrenaline in a can. The. Let's go build something that, you know, flies off of a pier and makes you float in the air. Right. Like, that's craziness. And when you think about caffeine, you think about coffee. Coffee's a cozy beverage. When you really think about the core, like back in the day, original Starbucks concept. And when coffee really took off in this country, it was this cozy vibe. Coffee is actually a relaxing source of caffeine.
Keren Novack 11:46 Yeah.
Simon Solis-Cohen 11:46 And so that's what I think is interesting. And what was missing in an energy quote unquote drink in a camp.
Keren Novack 11:51 Especially for that. After that afternoon, I still drink my coffee hot. In the morning, it can be 100 degrees outside. And I'm like, I know, I need, I need my warm coffee. There's something.
Simon Solis-Cohen 12:00 Exactly.
Keren Novack 12:03 Okay. Every founder has assumptions. And this is all sounded absolutely wonderful. Um, but what got challenged when your product actually met real consumers? Was there an assumption you made at launch that consumers, you know, they're real honest, Right. That they proved wrong? -Cohen: Exactly. Okay. Every founder has assumptions. And this is all sounded absolutely wonderful. Um, but what got challenged when your product actually met real consumers? Was there an assumption you made at launch that consumers, you know, they're real honest, Right. That they proved wrong?
Simon Solis-Cohen 12:22 Yeah, no, I mean, it's an interesting question. I think that from a product perspective, I'll be honest. I, I, I, I think we've always been right on with the product. Like, we really haven't had to change aspects of the product. You know, I think like, I think I feel like the strawberry just like tweaked a little bit of the flavor after the first batch just to, just to dial that in a little bit. But I think that's really the only, if I'm like, just thinking back, that's the only thing I've changed. Right?
Keren Novack 12:48 Like strawberries flavor too.
Simon Solis-Cohen 12:51 Yeah. We were just trying to just get it right because, you know, strawberry juice is not something people are used to as a flavor. Because that's the thing. It's like with the irony. I mean, I got this great, like, I love the hate I get. It's some of my favorite things. Right? And so with we got some like crappy one star review. I think it was on like Amazon or. No, it was on TikTok, I think. And some guys like, doesn't taste like strawberry. And I'm just like shaking my head because I'm like, dude, we are like literally the only energy drink I know of that actually uses real strawberry juice. Right? That is after water. Real fruit juice is the number one ingredient of our products. So I'm like, there's real strawberry juice and there's a lot of real strawberry juice. It's like 10% strawberry juice. If you look at that. Wow. Insane. So someone's been like, it doesn't taste like real strawberry. Not that, you know, we had made the tweaks, the little tweak to the formula. And I'm not going to change it just because that one guy said that. But that's where I'm just like, it's so interesting how people perceive things because what people are used to is artificial strawberry. They're used to candy, right? This explosion of fake flavor. And so I think that we are never going to, you know, change our thesis on this. But what I think we've seen is people catching up to our vision of this, which is that some people, I think when we do get negative criticism, they're like, it's not flavorful enough. And what I think is interesting is that they're expecting these loud, screaming, artificial flavors. They're expecting overly sweet profiles. And like, the irony of like the zero sugar movement. Zero sugar is not anti sweet. All those fake sugars people are using aren't typically anti way sweeter than sugar when you actually go gram for gram, right? And so people are just used to this explosion of sugar sensation. It's not sugar, but the sugar sensation. So sweet sensation, the explosion of fake artificial flavors. And then they have something real. And there might be that one moment of letdown for some people, not all, but just for a small minority of consumers who've given us this feedback is they're expecting the big. sation. It's not sugar, but the sugar sensation. So sweet sensation, the explosion of fake artificial flavors. And then they have something real. And there might be that one moment of letdown for some people, not all, but just for a small minority of consumers who've given us this feedback is they're expecting the big.
Keren Novack 14:50 Yeah.
Simon Solis-Cohen 14:50 And it's like. But no, that's not what this is. And I think something a lot of people have said is this is sort of like the spin drift of energy where Spindrift, you know, is this great product where it's real fruit juice and water and that's it. Right. There's no BS in it. Right. It's not these artificially flavored, you know, seltzers. And I think that's sort of that approach that we think about and what consumers like, that's where this product lives.
Keren Novack 15:12 It's interesting because you're almost in. In a. In a unique position where you need to educate consumers that if they were buying other energy drinks in the past, that this can still provide a lot of those benefits that you were looking for, but in a different type of way and a different type of experience. So there's an education component, would you say? in. In a. In a unique position where you need to educate consumers that if they were buying other energy drinks in the past, that this can still provide a lot of those benefits that you were looking for, but in a different type of way and a different type of experience. So there's an education component, would you say?
Simon Solis-Cohen 15:33 Yeah, there isn't. But I'd also say too, is that, you know, a lot of our consumers are not energy drinkers. And that's the most interesting part about it. Interesting. So for me, and like, you know, to be clear, like, I coming to this, you know, idea was never an energy drink consumer. I never had an energy drink in my life before I started this company. I only tasted them during this R and D process just to see what was out there. But I would never drink those because one, I'm super sensitive to caffeine, so I can't do these 200 milligram drinks that would, like, kill me. And two, I think a lot of them personally aren't very tasty. It's just not something that I think is delicious. And then finally, the ingredients Right. I don't want to put artificial sweeteners in my body. I don't want to put artificial flavors in my body. And so, you know, personal preference there. But that's just how I live my life. And so for me, I wanted to create something I actually would drink. And I had this, you know, thesis, which I'm sure a lot of CPG founders do. It's like, you know, if I feel this way, there's probably millions of other consumers who feel this way, and we've proven that alone with just what we're seeing out there is that we're not just saying, cool, if we could just get 1% market share from Red Bull, we're rich. Right? Like, that's not the thesis of this company. The thesis of this company is, can we expand this category? Can we pull a consumer to buy this product that was never shopping the energy set? And that's part of this repositioning we just announced, and we're officially, you know, kicking off in the next, you know, month or so with the actual cans now. We just produced the cans literally, like, last week, where they're shipping to our warehouse right now, where we just simply change from saying energy drink to energy refresher, where we haven't actually changed anything that's in the drink. It's the same, you know, formula we've had since day one. But we just realized that this term energy drink is very polarizing. There is a stigma, and at the end of the day, doesn't matter how differentiated the product is, doesn't matter how much education you provide. There's just some people who are just, I'm never going to drink an energy drink.
Keren Novack 17:28 That's interesting because usually founders are receiving feedback and tweaking the formula. You are receiving feedback around how the concept was landing with them and how the product can better fit a different. A different concept. That's fascinating. I'm never going to drink an energy drink. That's interesting because usually founders are receiving feedback and tweaking the formula. You are receiving feedback around how the concept was landing with them and how the product can better fit a different. A different concept. That's fascinating.
Simon Solis-Cohen 17:44 Exactly right. And so what I was seeing out there in the market was just the rise of what is now dubbed energy refreshers. And it's just simply stated, this is what we've always been. I just never had the term. I never had the language to describe it because it didn't exist. Right. And so Starbucks gets all the credit for creating this. Right? They've had refreshers for, I think, about a decade or more now. Right? You know, cool little lemonades and stuff like that. And then it's just April of 2026 that they officially rebranded it as an energy refresher. And they even commented on their public earnings Calls that they're okay if people stick the name. Like they purposely, we've checked, they haven't trademarked it and they said, you know, one of the executives said in the earnings call, I'm not going to exactly quote this. Right. But paraphrase, essentially, we think it's okay if a lot of other people are doing this because it only strengthens their halo and their position.
Keren Novack 18:34 Well, now I know what I'm buying because I've started to see that in other places. And actually, honestly, seeing it on your shirt here, energy refresher, it makes it, it's, it's bringing me to that. Oh, that's a, that's familiar to me. I now know what that is. It's not going to give me the wired jitters of, you know, one of the other drinks that maybe we won't name today. But yeah, not to again, not to throw. There's, as you said, there's a TAM big enough for everybody here and probably increasing with this repositioning, I would imagine. liar to me. I now know what that is. It's not going to give me the wired jitters of, you know, one of the other drinks that maybe we won't name today. But yeah, not to again, not to throw. There's, as you said, there's a TAM big enough for everybody here and probably increasing with this repositioning, I would imagine.
Simon Solis-Cohen 19:10 Oh, I think so. You know, and for me, I just saw this, you know, I'd say first to shelf opportunity here where all we have to do is change one word drink to refresher. But we've now even carved our own path in our own lane even more. And you know, this energy refresher thing is just like wildfire in QSRs. Quick service restaurants, right? Like Dunkin had theirs, I think about a year now. Um, you know, and right now I, I, I read that, you know, these cold beverages outsell hot coffee at Dunkin now. Right? Incredible. Right? And they're seeing massive growth within that platform. You know, Sonic is out there, Panera's out there, Pete's coffee is out there. I mean, I could just go on and on and on. Everyone has these refreshers now and I don't think it's a trend. I really don't. I truly believe this is a new category. Right. And it's something that will sustain because, you know, sure, maybe one day it's less Instagramable because there'll be something cute that comes next. That's just the next trend. But I just think it's going to be an enduring part of menus because there's nothing trendy about refreshment. That is something you need every day. And what I love about it, it's not locked into some health outcome. Right. So many of these trendy food and drink fads are diet related. Let's be super honest about it. There's nothing necessarily diet related. About a refresher. It's just a pure moment of enjoyment and that's what I think may is going to make this enduring.
Keren Novack 20:32 Yeah, yeah. Interesting. Now, I was listening to one of the podcasts that you had done previously with somebody else. It was super fascinating to hear your story and dive more into that, those details. But I think you mentioned at one point that you expected Huxley to resonate with the Gen Zs, but you were surprised by the response from some of the older consumers. Tell me a little bit about that and who's buying Huxley today? y else. It was super fascinating to hear your story and dive more into that, those details. But I think you mentioned at one point that you expected Huxley to resonate with the Gen Zs, but you were surprised by the response from some of the older consumers. Tell me a little bit about that and who's buying Huxley today?
Simon Solis-Cohen 20:57 Yeah, no, it's been an interesting thing. You know, we, you know, have this original thesis of like, let's be honest, you know, younger folks especially, you know, Gen Z at the age now is, you know, in college and just getting out of college now where like, okay, we all know those folks are consuming tons of caffeine, obviously. But what we are seeing is that, you know, in just engaging with that generation, not that they don't drink Huxley, but a lot of them are less, you know, specific about quality of ingredients. You know, they are more on, hey, whatever's on sale and cheapest. You know, what we're seeing is that there is not brand loyalty in that generation with these beverages, right. I've poured through tons of Mentel research and things like that. And you know, these consumers are drinking multiple brands, you know, and I'm just seeing that anecdotally when we do tons of events and tastings and demos, I'm always asking people, you know, what do you drink? And what's so fascinating is they list multiple brands. There wasn't that brand loyalty in that generation. And I said a lot of it was price driven and just access driven. Right? And let's just be honest, like if you're in college, you're not ordering Huxley by the case online. That's just not happening. You know, they're going to whatever their local stores and buying a can for the day, right? And so then that becomes a distribution game of just getting the distribution to get access to that customer, which is, you know, obviously something we're working on, but that's not an overnight thing. And so what we're seeing is actually looking at the data, who's actually buying it. Especially, you know, look, it's very hard to get consumer data out of grocery stores, right? You can, you can buy your way into that, but that's very, very expensive to do. The consumer data we get access to is our DTC data, right? So we're getting that Through Amazon, we're getting that through our own, you know, Shopify based, you know, website where we can then also send out surveys and get information. And what we're just seeing at least online is it is an older consumer, you know, it's not the 20, you know, 18 to 20 year old. You know, we're seeing a massive sweet spot in my generation, Millennials, you know, we're seeing that. Where we're really resonating on Amazon is actually this about 35 to 45. That's really our largest swath of customers on Amazon right now. And to me that's super interesting. And you know, trying to backdoor explain why that is now that we have the answer, trying to say, well, why is that? Our assumptions are, well, that's a generation that has more disposable income obviously than Gen Z. That's obvious. But then number two, that's at the age you really start thinking about what you're putting in your body. That's the age a lot of people are really starting to think about longevity and wellness and things like that. And I politely say maturing out of some of the behaviors and beverages they might have indulged in in university college age. And so we're seeing is that, that's when they're making that flip over. But it's sustaining too. Like we have a lot of baby boomers, you know, who are buying this in the data, which is incredible. You know, we do events and you know, we're seeing people in their 60s and 70s. We have grandparents coming and buying this. And I can just make an assumption. I doubt a lot of grandparents are buying some of our competitor legacy energy brands out there. , you know, who are buying this in the data, which is incredible. You know, we do events and you know, we're seeing people in their 60s and 70s. We have grandparents coming and buying this. And I can just make an assumption. I doubt a lot of grandparents are buying some of our competitor legacy energy brands out there.
Keren Novack 24:04 You know, to your point, you're cap a newer, a newer audience that maybe wasn't part of that original energy market tam that you were talking about earlier.
Simon Solis-Cohen 24:15 Exactly. No, that's exactly right, yeah.
Keren Novack 24:17 Interesting. There's always a part of the story here that doesn't, doesn't quite flow as well as you thought. You've been very good clearly at creating this momentum and articulating the vision. Has there been any part of building this company that has been a bit messier than the story suggests?
Simon Solis-Cohen 24:40 You know, I think that the most challenging thing, but it's not a shock to anyone who is working in this industry is just retail is very hard. You know, that's not a shock, you know, but that's just the reality of the situation, you know, especially in a very competitive category. I just had the luck to choose literally one of the hardest categories out there to try to try to build a business in, you know. And so, you know, what I think is challenging always is that depending on the retailers, you get one shot a year to submit. And if you don't get chosen that year, you gotta wait a whole nother year for the next review. Right. And so, you know, as I've been building and learning this industry well, it's just accepting that, you know, like, yes, you can get cut in sometimes. And we've been fortunate to have some retail partners who are just so excited. They're just like, cool, I want this right now. And that's also. Yeah, but I think that just, you know, learning the kind of calendar of CPG has been very interesting and humbling and then knowing you really do get just one shot sometimes to make that first impression. And you know, of course we get rejections, you know, like, of course there's people who say, no, we're not interested. And of course that hurts, you know, and it can feel like we are doing literally everything right. And we just can't sway some people. Right. And sometimes there's good reason, sometimes we don't get a reason. Right. We get no feedback. And for me, that's the most frustrating when retailers don't give feedback at all. You know, but we've had cases without naming names where, you know, at a chain, the person essentially was just like, nope, I don't personally like it. And that's why they bring it in. And then I asked, you know, our broker, okay, like, what is that? Do you know what that person normally drinks? And that person is drinking a legacy brand artificial high octane adrenaline energy drink. Right. They're expecting that overly sweet, artificial sugar, artificial flavor explosion.
Keren Novack 26:34 Yeah. then I asked, you know, our broker, okay, like, what is that? Do you know what that person normally drinks? And that person is drinking a legacy brand artificial high octane adrenaline energy drink. Right. They're expecting that overly sweet, artificial sugar, artificial flavor explosion. Yeah.
Simon Solis-Cohen 26:34 So when you have something that's real and a little bit more mild in terms of the caffeine dose of 90 milligrams versus say 200, it isn't what they're used to. And for that personal reason, they rejected us. And look, I'm not a buyer. I've never been. I can only imagine how hard it is. But that sucks, right? When it's just like personal opinion gets in the way of empirical data. And I'm maybe to a fault, so data driven. And it's like we can put the best case studies, we can put the best sales story in front of them, but sometimes that doesn't move the needle. And so that's humbling. And that's where you just have to learn. And that also is why we've, we've repositioned this as a refresher, because I was sick of the comparisons. I was sick of being compared to every other energy drink when, let's be honest, this is a very different product.
Keren Novack 27:20 Yeah, that's fascinating. I think that's, that's really going to resonate, Resonate well. And I love what you're saying about, you know. Yeah. At the end of the day, you have to trust the consumer. You have to trust the data that you're getting from, from the consumer. I see, I see a lot of founders and retailers fall into the trap of, well, I like it, so it must be great. And you've done an incredible job of taking a step back and going, how's this positioned to differentiate itself, to be true to the product that it is? And I think taking a step back and like, who is buying this and then adjusting based off of that. So really awesome. Would love to test this in the Kurion ecosystem because I suspect that this would be a five star product, as we call it. It is absolutely delicious. Absolutely delicious. All right, Simon, as we round out the episode here, I like to do a shelf check, coup, rapid fire questions for you. What is one drink that you would never want to see in a drink again? One ingredient. I'm sorry, let me, let me start that one again. What's one ingredient you never want to see in a drink again?
Simon Solis-Cohen 28:32 Sucralose.
Keren Novack 28:35 Absolutely. In, in my post college era, there was a lot of, a lot of that and found a real difference when I stopped, stopped drinking and eating so much of the fake shit.
Simon Solis-Cohen 28:49 I think we are going to have a sucralose reckoning one day. I think what the backlash we saw to aspartame and Coke and things like that. I think that's coming for Sucralose. I'm just calling it. It might take longer than I want it to, but I think one day we're going to look back and say, I can't believe we drank that and I can't believe we let our children drink that. one day. I think what the backlash we saw to aspartame and Coke and things like that. I think that's coming for Sucralose. I'm just calling it. It might take longer than I want it to, but I think one day we're going to look back and say, I can't believe we drank that and I can't believe we let our children drink that.
Keren Novack 29:08 Yeah. All right, this one's going to touch back on what we were just talking about. But when Founder Instinct. Or maybe I'll say when retailer Instinct. I'll start with Founder. When Founder Instinct and Consumer Data disagree, who gets the final vote?
Simon Solis-Cohen 29:25 The wrong answer, but the honest answer is probably my founder instinct. I mean, I really do let the data talk to me.
Keren Novack 29:31 Yep.
Simon Solis-Cohen 29:32 But then I think you also need to have a little bit of Steve Jobs in you as a founder. Right. And Steve Jobs is very famous for saying consumers don't know what they want until you give it to them.
Keren Novack 29:42 Interesting. Yeah, I like that there's definitely let the data talk to me. That's generally going to be my instinct. But you have to know what you're building. You have to, most importantly, believe in what you're building as a founder and have that passion for it. So I think that's really important. Thinking about retail shelves too crowded or not innovative enough?
Simon Solis-Cohen 30:07 Both, honestly, isn't it? They, they are too crowded with the same product. You know, I respectfully believe the majority, not all, the majority of energy drinks out there today are the exact same product with a different color can on the outside. There is very little innovation on what's inside the can. Anyone can put 200 milligrams in a can. Anyone can add sucralose and claim zero sugar. And then how they differentiate is just a different color can. And so I think that I'd love to see more real innovation and kind of clear the field of all the me toos out there.
Keren Novack 30:49 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. All right, my favorite and last question here. What's the better predictor of long term success for the brand? Is it product experience or branding?
Simon Solis-Cohen 31:02 Oof. I want it to be product experience, but I think it is branding. Honestly, there's bad products that win. It happens. Right. And so that's just why I think it's branding, because let's be honest, there's some stuff that isn't the greatest product out there yet. It's been very, very successful. And so inversely, there's a lot of incredible products that I've tried that have gone out of business or just haven't taken off. And you're like, why? This thing is delicious.
Keren Novack 31:33 Yeah.
Simon Solis-Cohen 31:33 So unfortunately, I do think at the end of the day, especially in beverage, more than anything, branding is really the key. dible products that I've tried that have gone out of business or just haven't taken off. And you're like, why? This thing is delicious.
Keren Novack 31:33 Yeah.
Simon Solis-Cohen 31:33 So unfortunately, I do think at the end of the day, especially in beverage, more than anything, branding is really the key.
Keren Novack 31:41 Yeah, you might, you might. You're definitely onto something there. I think there's a synergy between the two. They have to be symbiotic. Right. If you've got bad branding and a great product, you're not going to win. But if you've got a great product and your branding is not connected to your point, if we were still calling this an energy drink, it might cause, you know, it might not grow as much as it's going to be when the branding and the positioning all match in together.
Simon Solis-Cohen 32:09 Right, exactly.
Keren Novack 32:11 Yeah. Really interesting perspective. I appreciate that. And for going against the grain a little bit on typically what I hear. So I do appreciate that. Simon, thank you for joining us on behind the Shelf and I think it's just very refreshing to see what happens when we disrupt a category not by adding more, but kind of stripping back to what is the real ingredients and what people actually want out of it, which is incredible product here. So kudos to you.
Simon Solis-Cohen 32:38 Oh, thank you so much. Appreciate it.
Keren Novack 32:42 Awesome. All right, I'm going to stop the recording in a second, but I'm kind of making a note to myself. I may cut that last question around the messy part that didn't come follow the story just so we can edit or just so that we can end on a higher note than what didn't work. But we'll let's see how the episode kind of rolls out there. All right.